Skip to main content

Stringing Issues

ยท 8 min read

Stringing Issuesโ€‹

What Is It?โ€‹

Stringing is denoted as the oozing of filament from the nozzle when the print head travels between two points on your 3D model. It's caused due to excess filament oozing out of the nozzle due to improper retraction settings or high filament temperature.

Stringing issues result in extra efforts during the post-processing to clean your prints and might still leave small blobs or dots on the print's surface. Although it might not affect the print's structural integrity in severe cases, it impacts the print quality and is an undesirable attribute for printing aesthetic or showpiece items.

What to check?โ€‹

  1. Retraction settings
  2. Printing temperature
  3. Hot end movement settings

How to Fix It?โ€‹

Increase the Retraction Distanceโ€‹

Retraction distance controls the amount of filament pulled back into the hot end at the end of an extrusion path. A higher value will retract more filament, which is favorable for avoiding stringing issues. But, if you pull back too much filament, it might result in a nozzle clog.

The retraction distance depends on your extruder system. A direct drive extruder will have a lower distance as it needs to pull back a small amount of filament. In contrast, a Bowden extrusion system will have higher distance values ranging between 5-7 mm.

There's no single correct retraction distance value that'll resolve your stringing issues. But, you can try increasing it by 1 mm for every print until there are no strings on your part. You can use this Retraction Tuning guide from Teaching Tech to dial in your retraction settings.

Increase Retraction Speedโ€‹

Similar to the retraction distance, the speed of retraction is the rate at which the extruder pulls back the material into the hot end. A high retraction speed will result in quick filament retraction, leading to less filament oozing and reduced print times.

You can try to increase the retraction speed at 10 mm/s intervals and use the Teaching Tech's guide to fine-tune this setting.

Lower the Print Temperatureโ€‹

A higher printing temperature will cause excess melting of your filament, making it more viscous and easy to flow out of the hot end. It will result in filament oozing out of your nozzle, even if you have a high-retraction distance.

You need to lower the filament printing temperature by 5 ยฐC intervals from your current setting and observe its effects on your retraction issues. But, do not lower it by more than 20-25 ยฐC; otherwise, you might experience under extrusion or nozzle clogging issues.

Combing and Coasting Settingsโ€‹

The combingsetting restricts the nozzle within the printed areas while making travel movements. This way, the nozzle always travels over the printed part, and even if there's any filament oozing, it's within the 3D part's region. Combing effectively reduces the need for retractions and decreases visible stringing issues on your 3D prints.

On the other hand, Coasting limits the filament flow during an extrusion's end. Instead of the nozzle extruding till the end point, using coasting, you can replace the end of the extrusion path with a simple travel move. In short, coasting allows you to stop filament flow before it reaches the endpoint, thus reducing filament oozing from the nozzle.

The parameters for combing and coasting settings differ for each print and material; hence, you'll need to calibrate them extensively to eliminate your stringing issues. The name of both these features is particular to Cura, but they're available in PrusaSlicer, Simplify3D, and other slicers with similar names or terms.

Warping and Split Layersโ€‹

What Is It?โ€‹

Warping or curling occurs mainly on the initial few layers of your part, leading to a failed print, poor print quality, or a dimensionally inaccurate part. Whereas layer splitting usually takes place in the middle of the top portion of your printed pieces. Split layers directly affect your part's structural integrity, resulting in an unappealing-looking 3D print.

The primary reasons behind both these problems are the printing temperature and ambient temperature of your 3D print. If there's a significant difference between your hot and bed temperature and the surrounding environment, you will experience warping and layer splitting in your 3D-printed parts.

What to Check?โ€‹

  • Printing temperature
  • Heated Bed temperature
  • Ambient printing temperature
  • Cooling settings
  • Material properties (Type of material, ABS, PETG, PP)

How to Fix It?โ€‹

Increase the Print Bed and Hot End Tempโ€‹

A heated bed reduces the thermal shock that the extruded material experiences during the few initial layers of your print. It maintains a warm surrounding temperature and lowers the temperature difference between your printer's environment and the 3D print.

Likewise, if your printing temperature is low, the extruded filament will not bond properly with the previous layer, resulting in layer separation.

Specifically, ABS, PETG, PC, and PA need a high-temperature heated bed to avoid warping issues. You can try increasing the heated bed temperature by 10 ยฐC and keep the hot end temperature towards the higher end.

For example, if your ABS filament has a printing temperature range of 195 - 225 ยฐC, try printing it at around 215 - 220 ยฐC. Similarly, if your print bed setting is at 90 ยฐC, try to bump it up to 100 - 110 ยฐC if your printer supports these temperatures. It should minimize the chances of split layers and warping issues in your prints. For a full material temperature guide, Prusa has developed this tool for reference.

Enclose your 3D printerโ€‹

A 3D printer enclosure isolates your machine's surroundings and maintains an optimal printing environment. A well-designed enclosure will trap the heat from the print bed and maintain a warm ambient printing temperature. Additionally, an enclosure prevents sudden cold air drafts that might induce a temperature difference in your prints and split the layers.

Several DIY enclosure designs are available, using which you can create a customized enclosure for your 3D printer. Otherwise, you can also buy pre-made enclosures for your printer, but it might be hard to find an enclosure mainly manufactured for your 3D printer.

An enclosure is necessary if you print ABS, PETG, and other high-temperature materials. It will reduce the chances of warping and help improve the chances of a successful print with these materials.

Shut off the cooling fanโ€‹

The cooling fan induces a cool air breeze on your 3D prints creating a temperature difference between the current and the previous layers. This difference causes the layers to split or curl up, leading to failed prints.

It's a well-established practice to shut off the part cooling fan for the initial layers regardless of your filament. But, with high-temperature filaments, it's best to keep the fan off for the entire duration of the 3D print.

Adjust layer heightsโ€‹

A high layer height increases the gap between two layers, and if the temperature isn't high enough or you're printing without an enclosure, there's a high chance of layer separation. A high layer height setting results in thick layers that need more time to cool down. If these thick layers aren't cooled down properly, they'll split and warp during printing.

As a thumb rule, your layer height should be more than 80 % nozzle diameter. Therefore, if you're printing with a 0.4 mm nozzle, the maximum layer height should be around 0.28 - 0.32 mm for your prints. If you're experiencing split layers, try reducing your layer heights gradually and find a sweet spot that balances your print times and quality.

Use A Temperature Tower To Calibrate Filament Temperatureโ€‹

A temperature tower is a quick and easy way to find the optimal temperature settings for your filament. These towers help determine the temperature range for the particular filament, and it would be best if you'd print them whenever you load a new roll of filament material.

Several temperature towers are available on Thingiverse with detailed instructions and settings. Alternatively, you can use the Teaching Tech's guide to create your customized temperature tower and test the printing temperature range for your filament.

Use a Remote monitoring toolโ€‹

In some cases, warped bottom layers can weaken the print's adhesion to the bed surface, causing it to peel away from the print bed. If this goes unchecked, the following layers will continue to pile up, but result in a noodle-like mess on your bed. It will lead to a loss of your 3D printing filament and your printer's printing time.

To prevent this, you can use tools like Obico to quickly diagnose any failed prints, and stop the printing immediately, from anywhere. Obico will automatically notify you if the print is not peeled away from the bed, and you can take prompt action to further save the loss of filament.